Monica Badiu, Email Copywriter & Copy Coach

Most abandoned cart optimization advice is written for ecommerce: physical products, product images, discount codes, urgency timers. The playbook is well-worn and mostly borrowed from retail.

So it’s no surprise course creators don’t think this tactic applies to them, and for good reason: course businesses are different, and so are the objections and the psychology of the buyer. 

This case study documents what happened when we ran a systematic testing program on a three-email abandoned cart flow for an online training business — one where the checkout serves multiple courses at once, which means the emails can’t speak to the specific course a person left behind. 

Over the course of three months, we ran more than ten A/B tests across the three emails in this flow. Some had clear winners, some were inconclusive but all of them taught us something. 

I’ll walk you through the key themes — what we tested, why, and what the data actually showed.

If you want the deep dive on what happened when we added a third email to this flow specifically, I covered that in a separate case study here. This piece is about the full picture.

First, a word on what each email in the sequence is actually supposed to do

Before you can test anything in an abandoned cart flow, you need a clear perspective of what each email is trying to accomplish, because the job shifts significantly from one email to the next.

I’ll make this specific to the flow featured in this case study, but at a 80% overview, these insights would apply to other brands as well.

Email one goes out within two to four hours of abandonment. 

At this stage, most people who left the checkout did so because something interrupted them — a notification, a distraction, a moment of “I’ll come back to this later.” They haven’t made a decision against buying, they’ve just paused, that’s the assumption we’re making about their behavior at this point.

So email one’s job is simple: be a warm, low-friction reminder that removes the need to go looking for the page again. The tone should feel like a helpful nudge, not a sales pitch.

Looking back at our case study, we’ve got data to reflect this. Email 1 consistently delivers the highest open rates in the flow, ranging from 66% to 74% month over month, and the highest CTR, regularly sitting between 9% and 15%.

Email two goes out roughly 23 hours later, to the people who saw the first reminder and still didn’t act.

By now, the interruption excuse is gone, something else is keeping them from completing the purchase — uncertainty about whether it will work for them, doubt about the format, a concern about wasting money, or just inertia.

Email two’s job is to reduce friction and reinforce motivation, not to remind — they know — but to reassure. Open rates here drop to 58–65%, CTR to 5–10% which tells us that the audience is more hesitant by definition.

Email three lands 24 hours after that, roughly 48 hours after the initial abandonment.

The people still in the sequence at this point are the most resistant segment of the entire checkout audience. They’ve seen two follow-ups and haven’t taken action so the doubt at this stage is usually specific and for a course business, the most common version is: “Can an online course actually help with my unique situation?”

Email three’s job is to answer that question directly, with proof. Open rates here range from 56% to 67%, which is still remarkably strong for a third touch, and placed order rates hold between 1.1% and 1.6%.

Together, the three emails generated $27,392 in tracked revenue across the period measured.

Email one contributed the largest share, but the second and third emails recover revenue that would otherwise be permanently lost — and that’s before any optimization work has even started.

What to test in an abandoned cart flow for courses

Test type 1: Structure and layout matter more than most people think

The first test we ran on Email 1 was structural. The control version opened with a neutral “Thanks for stopping by” message, followed by a large hero image with the CTA button embedded inside it. The CTA was below the fold on most mobile screens and visually buried inside the graphic.

The hypothesis: if we move the CTA above the fold, add personalization in the headline, introduce a money-back guarantee section, and remove distracting footer content, we’ll increase clicks and purchases because people can understand the offer and act on it without scrolling.

The result was one of the clearest wins in the entire test program:

  • CTR jumped from 11.21% to 17.38%.
  • Revenue went from $49 (one order) to $725 (ten orders).
  • Revenue per recipient increased to $73.

The explanation is straightforward but important: in abandoned cart emails, intent is already high. The person knows why they’re getting this email, they don’t need to be convinced, but the transition to purchase needs to be very smooth. So every extra scroll, every buried button, every element that requires effort is friction that bleeds conversions.

Removing that friction can have a dramatic impact.

The same principle surfaced in Email 3’s CTR test, where we tested moving the CTA button above the testimonials versus leaving it at the bottom. Here the result was less clear — both versions produced similar revenue, and the control (button after testimonials) held a marginal edge. The likely reason: by email three, the audience needs to read the testimonials before they’re ready to click, so the trust-building comes first. Moving the button earlier assumes a readiness that isn’t there yet at this stage of the sequence. Same principle — make the action easy — but the application differs depending on where you are in the flow.

Test type 2: Subject lines — clarity versus curiosity, and when each wins

We ran subject line tests on all three emails, and the pattern that emerged across them is one of the most practically useful findings in this entire program.

On Email 1, we tested two variants against the control.

The first added first-name personalization. The second replaced the direct cart reminder with a curiosity-based, dog-focused subject line: “Forgetting something for your 🐾?” with the preview text “Life got in the way. We saved your cart.”

The personalization test was a clear non-result. Open rates barely moved, and more importantly, the personalized version generated zero clicks and zero revenue compared to the control’s $68. The explanation: in a transactional email where the recipient already knows why they’re hearing from you, adding their name to a subject line doesn’t change anything meaningful. The intent is already there, the name just feels like automation trying to seem personal.

The curiosity test told a different story.

  • Open rate increased from 62.5% to 70.21%.
  • CTR went from 8.33% to 10.64%.
  • Revenue went from $276 to $689.

Shifting the focus from the cart (“don’t forget your cart”) to the problem they’re aiming to solve (“forgetting something for your [problem]?”) triggered stronger emotional resonance. The reader isn’t thinking about the cart — they’re thinking about their problem, so meeting them where they are mentally outperformed meeting them where they are transactionally.

On Email 2, we ran two subject line tests.

The first compared the cart-focused control with an outcome-focused variant: “Still planning to get help [with your problem] today?” The emotional variant got higher open rates but lower CTR and less revenue, the mismatch between subject line and email body is likely the culprit — recipients opened expecting help or content, found a cart reminder, and the disconnect reduced conversion intent.

The second subject line test on Email 2 tried a continuation-based framing: “Pick up where you left off with your [desired outcome].” This version got lower open rates than the control but significantly more revenue — $524 versus $68 — from recipients who were fewer but more purchase-ready.

The framing of “continuing” rather than “starting” reduced perceived effort as it implied the decision had already been made. That resonated with the segment that was closest to converting.

On Email 3, we tested whether framing the subject line as a community invitation (“Become Part of Our 160,000+ Community!”) would outperform the authority-based control (“160,000+ [audience] Can’t Be Wrong”). The community version got a 7% higher open rate, but CTR was slightly weaker and neither version produced orders in the test window. The community framing increased curiosity but didn’t increase purchase intent — a pattern consistent with what we saw elsewhere: opens driven by emotional framing don’t always translate downstream, especially at this stage of the funnel where skepticism is highest.

The through-line across all the subject line tests:

clarity and transactional directness drives higher-quality opens in abandoned cart emails, but the best-performing tests found a way to balance that directness with emotional relevance. Problem-first framing consistently outperformed cart-first framing when the rest of the email aligned with it.

Test type 3: What you say above the fold determines whether the rest of the email gets read

Separate from the structural tests, we ran a hook test on Email 2 that specifically examined the opening copy — the first thing someone sees when they open the email.

The control opened with “Still thinking about it?”, a vague, internal hesitation frame, so the test variant opened with “Still looking for help [solving your problem]?” and added a line acknowledging the effort already made: “You’ve already found a class [to solve your problem]. Now it’s time to complete your order.”

The hypothesis was that starting with the reader’s actual problem — not a generic hesitation — would increase engagement because the email now directly reflects why they came to the brand in the first place. The test also introduced light personalization in the body copy, calling out that the reader had already taken a step and making the next action feel like a continuation rather than a new decision.

This test was still running at the time of writing so no concluded results are available yet, but the strategic logic is sound and consistent with what the subject line tests showed: in a flow where you can’t personalize by specific product, you can still personalize by problem. Referencing the reader’s reason for being there — not the mechanics of the abandoned cart — keeps the email feeling human rather than automated.

Test type 4: CTA copy — “start” versus “continue”

One of the most conceptually interesting tests in this program was a CTA copy test on Email 2, comparing “Start Training Now” against “Continue where you left off.”

The hypothesis is grounded in behavioral psychology.

“Start” implies a new commitment — effort, time, energy, “Continue” implies the decision is already made and just needs to be finalized. For someone who abandoned a cart, “continue” is more accurate and less psychologically costly as it closes a mental loop rather than opening a new one.

We also deliberately avoided the word “training” in the variant, because the data suggested this audience views training as high-effort, even when they want the outcome.

This test was not yet live at the time of writing, so no results are available, but it represents one of the cleaner hypotheses in the program, and the strategic reasoning is directly informed by the subject line findings — specifically the “pick up where you left off” subject line that drove significantly higher revenue per recipient despite lower open rates.

Test type 5: Adding a third email — the short version

Adding Email 3 to this flow generated $2,440 in its first four full months of operation — October 2025 through January 2026 — from a sequence that previously stopped at two emails. February 2026 alone added another $1,094 as send volume scaled.

Based on current placed order rates and AOV, Email 3 is on track to generate over $12,000 annually and that number grows with the list.

The full breakdown of Email 3’s strategy, copy decisions, and split tests is in this case study. The short version: a third email works when it does a different job from the first two, not more urgency or another reminder, but a specific, named objection addressed with depth and social proof, arriving at the moment when the remaining audience is most skeptical and most in need of reassurance rather than pressure.

What the overall flow looks like now, and what’s still being tested

Across all three emails, the flow has generated $27,392 in tracked revenue. Email 1 leads in volume and conversion rate. Email 2 is the most extensively tested email in the sequence, with five tests run or planned, and the current best-performing variant improves on the control in both CTR and revenue. Email 3 is newer but scaling steadily.

What this program demonstrates, more than any single test result, is that abandoned cart optimization is not a one-time project, but a process of forming hypotheses about why people aren’t converting at each specific stage of the sequence, testing those hypotheses systematically, and implementing what works.

The technical constraint here — a general checkout that can’t serve course-specific copy — is real, and it limits how personalized the emails can get, but it doesn’t limit how strategically they can be written.

Understanding the psychological state of the reader at each touchpoint, and writing to that state rather than to the transaction, is what separates an abandoned cart flow that quietly recovers revenue from one that just sends reminders into the void.

If you want this kind of work done in your business

Abandoned cart optimization is one of the highest-leverage places to focus in any course business with an existing email platform. You don’t need more traffic or a new offer. You need a systematic look at where buyers are leaving and what it would take to bring them back.

The work I do with clients here is hands-on: auditing what’s already running, identifying the highest-impact tests to run first, writing the copy, and tracking what the data says over time. It’s highly personalized, so every recommendation is built around your audience, your products, and your data.

If your checkout is leaking revenue and your current abandoned cart flow is either non-existent or hasn’t been touched in months, that’s exactly the kind of problem I work on. Get in touch by booking a discovery call here.

About the Author

Monica Badiu is an email revenue strategist and conversion copywriter who helps course creators turn their email lists into reliable revenue systems.

With over 17 years of marketing experience and more than 25,000 hours spent studying and practicing customer-centric email marketing, she specializes in diagnosing the gaps that prevent email from performing at its full potential. Her strategies have helped course creators generate over $3 million in revenue, and her work focuses on building thoughtful email systems that drive sales while strengthening genuine relationships with audiences.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}