Estimated reading time: 2 minutes

Every course creator realizes this at some point: you have a lot of emails. 

A welcome sequence, a launch sequence, a webinar follow-up, some kind of evergreen thing that runs in the background. Each one was probably written with real thought and yet, revenue still is unpredictable and it depends more on which promotion you happen to be running that month than on anything actually working together underneath it.

I see this often, and while there’s no magical secret recipe for turning things around, here’s what we did for a course creator last year.

Here’s what we found after auditing his email system 

Performance was inconsistent. Average click-through rate sat at 1.61% — well under the 3.7% benchmark for creators on his platform. Open rates were actually solid, at nearly 49% against a 43% benchmark, which told us something specific: the problem wasn’t getting emails opened, it was what happened after someone opened one.

One automation was performing well. The other was underwater, right next to it. He had two lead magnets feeding two separate welcome sequences, tied to his two core products. One sequence was outperforming the other by a wide margin — a 66% open rate and nearly 17% click rate on its first email, against 60% and 9% for the other. By the final enrollment email in each sequence, the stronger one was pulling an 11.6% click rate; the weaker one had fallen to 4%. Two automations, teaching two products from the same business, performing like they belonged to two different creators.

There was no welcome sequence at all for anyone entering the list outside those two specific paths. Someone who joined the list any other way had nothing built to greet them.

62% of his entire list, over its lifetime, had unsubscribed. Against a typical healthy range of 20-40% lifetime for an engaged list, that’s a real gap. And nearly 4,000 subscribers — over 19% of the active list — were already cold: no opens or clicks in the last 90 days, with no automated system in place to re-engage or clean them.

A near-miss with no plan behind it. In one month alone, the list had grown by almost 4,000 subscribers overnight. Genuinely good news, except there was no onboarding sequence ready to catch that spike, so a huge one-time opportunity to build a relationship with thousands of new people got treated the same as any ordinary week.

Broadcast emails to the full list underperformed badly compared to smaller, more engaged segments — a strong early signal that everyone on the list was being spoken to the same way, regardless of how warmed up they actually were.

And the important KPIs were not being tracked. Revenue per subscriber, bounce and spam rates, and conversion from email to paying student weren’t being tracked at all. Decisions were being made on instinct because the data to make them with simply wasn’t there yet.

None of this reflected a lack of effort, the individual pieces that did exist were genuinely strong on their own. It reflected a business running several disconnected experiments instead of one coordinated system, with no visibility into which parts were actually working.

Over the year, this stopped being a list of individual campaigns and started becoming a connected system, with a few core pieces working together:

A real welcome sequence, finally. Anyone entering the list outside of a specific funnel now gets an actual sequence — who he is, what to expect, and a bridge toward the next logical step — instead of landing in a gap and waiting for the next broadcast email to notice them.

Segmented lead magnet paths, matched to actual fit. Instead of leaving two unequal automations running side by side, different lead magnets fed into different automations based on which of his two core products someone was actually a fit for. Someone showing interest in one specific path got asked directly, inside an automated email, what they were actually trying to achieve — and got redirected toward the right sequence based on the answer, instead of being pushed through a one-size-fits-all path.

A tripwire that turned first-time buyers into a distinct segment. Instead of every lead magnet subscriber staying in the same undifferentiated pool, buying the tripwire moved someone into a different category entirely — someone worth treating differently from someone who’d only ever opted in.

A tiered ascension path, not just one offer. He had a lower-cost, self-guided option and a higher-tier, more supported option above it. Instead of leaving that gap to close itself, we built a specific cross-sell sequence — including using real testimonials from actual participants in the higher tier — that planted the idea of the upgrade well before the moment someone was actually asked to consider it, so the offer felt familiar instead of sudden.

Webinar follow-up that matched what someone had actually experienced. Live attendees, replay watchers, and non-attendees stopped getting identical treatment. Each group got follow-up built around what they’d actually seen and how much urgency they’d actually felt, instead of one blanket sequence assuming everyone was in the same place.

A promotional cadence that reused instead of reinvented. Once a full year of monthly promotions existed, going into the next year meant pulling from a real calendar instead of starting from a blank page every time — refreshing what already worked instead of guessing at something new each month.

List-wide monetization, not just new-lead monetization. Webinar invitations went out to the entire list, not just recently warmed segments — treating a new webinar as a legitimate reason to re-engage subscribers who’d gone quiet, instead of writing them off or needing a separate “we miss you” sequence to reach them.

Why this matters if your emails feel disconnected from each other

Most course creators build their email system the same way it happened here originally: one piece at a time, whenever a specific need comes up. 

• A welcome sequence because someone said you should have one. 
• A launch sequence because a launch is coming. 
• A webinar follow-up because the webinar just happened. 

But without anyone stepping back to ask how they connect, or without ever actually checking the numbers behind each piece, you end up with a business that has a lot of emails and still can’t answer a simple question: what actually happens to someone from the moment they join your list to the moment they become a repeat customer?

By the end of the year, this wasn’t a collection of campaigns anymore, but it was a connected path: opt-in, segmented onward based on actual fit, a tripwire that shifted someone into buyer status early, webinar and promotional touchpoints that matched what stage someone was actually at, and an ascension path toward a higher-tier offer that had been planted well before it was ever pitched. 

Roughly 60% of total revenue was coming from the recurring promotional engine alone, on top of what the tripwire and ascension paths were generating in the background — because for the first time, each piece was doing its job and setting up the next one, and there was finally real data behind knowing it.

What Happens Next?

Just like a doctor doesn’t prescribe treatment before identifying the root cause, I don’t recommend new funnels, ads, emails, or offers until we understand where your business is losing momentum.

Sometimes the bottleneck is traffic.

Sometimes it’s positioning.

Sometimes it’s an offer that isn’t compelling enough.

Sometimes it’s a sales funnel that leaks buyers at every stage.

And sometimes the biggest bottleneck isn’t marketing at all—it’s unclear priorities or building things in the wrong order.

If you’d like someone in your corner to help prioritize, challenge assumptions, review your work, and keep momentum going, coaching is the next step.

Together we’ll:

• prioritize what actually moves revenue
• refine your positioning and offers
• build or optimize your funnels
• review copy and messaging
• analyze performance data
• identify new bottlenecks as your business grows

Instead of wondering what to work on next, you’ll always know the highest-leverage move, because every business eventually reaches another bottleneck.

So, the goal isn’t finding one perfect strategy, but continuously removing the biggest constraint to growth.

If that sounds good to you, start by filling in this form.